I think those reviews are probably a little unfair! Yes, they do feel subtly different, but I wouldn't say they were slippery.
The only thing I really noticed was that when you first put them on, they sound as if they've already been on the guitar for a few days! I didn't get that bright "fresh, new string" sound that I'd normally expect from an uncoated set.
Probably worth mentioning that I only found this on acoustic guitars, which are going to be more sensitive to little changes like this - there was no such problem with the electric strings. (At least as far as my tin ears could discern!)