I do love a Strat. Some can be a bit.... bloodless... for my ear. Typicallyy those that have noiseless pickups, and I wish they'd stop making the middle RWRP: one of the reasons I love Strats is they *don't* have humbuckers (which I just don't get on with.... probably the main reason that while many of my guitar heroes are LP players, they just aren't for me). Would never even consider a Strat with a HB in the bridge. Well... I might at the right price, but before it was even plugged in the HB would be ripped out and replaced with a HB-sized p90. The only real shame with a strat is the wiring excluding the neck and bridge option. I'm well empted to pick up one of those Firefly Strat copies and experiment with wiring it with a three-way - neck and mid, neck and bridge, mid and bridge. Those would be the killer sounds imo.
I love the look of the Strat Trem - just all part of the visual package. I dont use it much, though... I'm a small wobble at the end of a number guy. Otherwise, finger-vibrato and bending just came more naturally to my hands. I'd like to try a fixed bridge model, though it'd be a partsacaster undertaking given Fender's crap provision for left handers. Basically a regular Strat with a Tele three saddle bridge (compensated brass saddles, natch).
Thing is, though, not every guitar will work for everyone. There are a lot of guitars I'd never even consider playing because find them fugly (pointy stuff, stuff that screans eighties metal, and fancy-schmancy figured wood tops. Hate those. Then there are those I like but, like the OP's experience with Strats, I just can't get on with. As noted above, LPs are big in that for me - humbuckers being the real problem there I think; they all just sound like mud in my hands. I suspect I might get on better with one loaded with p90s.... certainly enjoy my HB DC Jnr.
What I've never been is an "only one type" of guitar guy. I long ago grew to despise the "palette of sound" bollocks a lot of players spout when trying to justify owning more instruments, but I *do* like to havea few variables. If a gutar feels, or even just looks, different in a way that appeals to me that day, I'll play it differently, play different stuff... that can be a good thing. For all the difference in scale length, picksups, and whatever there's precious little difference that matters in terms of my basic tone from one to the other, but the look and feel can ake a enormous difference to me. I've played much cheaper Strats that I enjoyed playing more than my old American Standard for the simple reason that the neck shape was better for me. That's an element I prize far over the pickups (as long as they work reliably and make a sound I like).